Plug into Safety
“Of the top five ‘shed hazards’ identified below, three relate to electrical safety:
storing mains-powered tools uncovered – 32%;
not checking leads or plugs for damage – 28%;
using mains-powered tools without Residual Current Device (RCD) protection – 26%;
storing unsecured tins of chemicals such as weed, pest killer or paint – 38% and
leaving the sharp edges of garden tools uncovered – 58%”
I’m normally pretty good at checking my cables and using the RCD but I must confess to being guilty to leaving the tools uncovered.
Thanks to Plug into Safety’s prompt I’ve done some more research into RCDs.
From: IET Wiring Matters Summer 2005
RCDs are defined by a series of electrical characteristics, three main characteristics are:
1. The rating of the device in amperes, I.
2. The rated residual operating current of the protective device in amperes, IΔn.
3. Whether the device operates instantaneously or incorporates an intentional time delay to permit discrimination. Such devices are called ‘S’ or Selective.
The first issue I looked at is if you’ve got an RCD in your consumer unit then do you also need one in your shed or plug socket?
I got the answer to this from the IET Autumn 2005 wiring matters. For outside equipment you want to have a RCD that protects the person (rather than just the equipment) this means that it must NOT be selective and that it MUST be rated for residual operating current not exceeding 30mA.
The second issue is if you have a consumer unit in your shed/garage then how do you stop faults there tripping the household one too?
This is where that “selective” rating comes in. “Discrimination” is when you have one or more RCDs in series and the one nearest the user would trip first, the one in the consumer unit would protect from faults occurring between the house and shed. So you won’t need to walk back to the house to reset a second circuit breaker.
My next question I asked to lots of people, the Electrical Safety Council answered it for me. Several people on various forums commented that their welders tripped their circuits.
Do Arc Welders always trip an RCD?
“The majority of arc welders in terms of design should not trip an RCD under normal operating conditions, particularly the type with a 13-amp plug. They do, however, use high starting currents, which means that circuit breakers can trip out – not RCDs. Most circuit breakers or RCBOs (which is a combination of both a circuit breaker and an RCD) typically installed in homes are not designed for high starting currents, and these may trip out with an arc welder. If in doubt, contact the manufacturer.”
For a similar reason it’s always a good idea to unwind and extension cables you before use. If you know that your equipment (welders, lathes, milling machines etc) has a high surge current requirement then let your electrician know and they can select the right type of MCB for your consumer unit.
Another issue with engineering equipment is that it can sometimes have three phase motors so I checked another issue with the Electrical Safety Council.
RCDs can’t be used with three phase equipment.
“This is a myth; they can. There is no difference between single-phase and three-phase equipment in terms of RCD protection. Three-phase is not very common in households.”
Many thanks to the Electrical Safety Council for taking time to answer my questions and for raising the awareness of shed safety issues.
Why not try the Electrical Safety Council “Shed week” personality test.
No Volt Release Switch
The RCD explained
Types of RCD